How to evaluate an AEO agency.
Twelve questions to ask. Four red flags. The hire-or-build decision. An honest framework for choosing the firm that engineers your visibility across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude. By Dr. Avinaash.
The market is young and noisy.
Eighteen months ago, "AEO" was not a category. Today, ninety-plus Indian agencies have added the acronym to their service pages. Some have done real work. Most have rebranded SEO services. A small number, perhaps a dozen, actually engineer the citation infrastructure that decides whether AI engines name your firm in answers.
If you are about to spend ₹12–35 lakh on a Growth Foundation engagement or ₹5–9 lakh per month on a retainer, the difference between the right firm and the wrong firm is six to nine months of compounding citation share. This is the buying framework we wish ₹50Cr+ Indian operators had when they asked us for the evaluation criteria.
Every Indian agency now claims AEO. Twelve questions separate the firms that ship from the firms that pitch. . Dr. Avinaash · Founder · e21designs
The twelve questions to ask.
Show me your published methodology. With named operating principles.
Real firms publish their methodology in full. Named layers. Named principles. Named tests. If the answer is "our proprietary process" without published depth, the methodology is theatre, not engineering. Ask to see the methodology page before the first commercial conversation.
What is your measurement instrument and how is it scored?
"AI citation share" is the right answer. A named composite score, on a 0–100 scale, with stated indicators and weighting, is better. "Monthly reporting on AI mentions" with no defined scoring is a soft answer. The firm should be able to show their own measurement methodology in a single page.
What original research have you published in the last twelve months?
AEO is a research-anchored discipline. Firms that have not run audits, published methodology essays, or shipped industry data in the previous year have not engaged with the category seriously. The firm worth hiring has published more than it has pitched.
Walk me through your last partner's schema deployment.
The candidate should be able to talk about Schema.org Organization, FAQPage, Speakable, Article with author Person entities, and sameAs cross-linking, in their own words, not a deck. If the partner asks you to repeat the question or pivots to "we work with developers", they do not run schema in-house.
Have you ever shipped an llms.txt file? Show me one.
llms.txt is the AI-era robots.txt. Firms that have shipped it can show three or four examples in fifteen seconds. Firms that cannot have not. This single artefact tells you whether the firm has actually deployed AEO at the engine-side level.
Tell me one thing each of ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude weights differently.
A serious AEO firm can answer this in two minutes. Perplexity weights Reddit ~24%. ChatGPT weights Wikipedia ~48% for biographical citations. Gemini weights Google-Extended signals. Claude weights long-context structured pages. A firm that treats "AI engines" as one bucket has not done the field work.
Have you ever earned a partner a Wikipedia article or Wikidata QID?
Wikipedia is the single most-cited biographical source by ChatGPT for Indian B2B firms (~48% of top-10 biographical citations). Firms that have shipped Wikipedia or Wikidata work for partners can name the article. Firms that have not, cannot.
What is your publishing cadence for partners, and who writes the content?
One pillar essay per quarter, anchored in original research, written by a named author, beats four blog posts per month written by a content team. Ask for the byline pattern and the cadence. The right answer is fewer, deeper, named pieces.
Show me an engagement that did not work and what you learned.
No firm wins every engagement. Firms that say they do are either lying or have not done enough work. A serious firm can name an engagement that plateaued, explain why, and tell you what they did about it (usually: extended at no cost, or returned scope). The willingness to publish failures is the single best filter for engineering integrity.
Do you work with my direct competitor?
Serious AEO firms do not. Category exclusivity is contractual, not a marketing promise. If the candidate firm works with three valve manufacturers, two hospital chains in your city, or two MBA programmes in your tier, walk. AEO at scale requires deep partner-side data; multiple competitors create real conflict.
How many partnerships do you run firm-wide each year?
The right answer is a number, not a range. "Ten partnerships per year, firm-wide" is operational discipline. "We scale with demand" is no answer. Senior partner attention is the single hardest thing for a young AEO market to deliver at volume; firms that cap intake are more likely to deliver it.
What does an engagement cost? Out loud, on a page, in writing.
Published pricing ranges are the strongest signal of operating maturity in this category. If the firm cannot put pricing in writing without "discovery call" gating, the pricing varies by what the buyer looks like they can pay. Premium B2B buyers above ₹50Cr revenue read concealed pricing as soft-extraction. Transparent pricing reads as confident.
The four red flags.
Red flag 01 · "We guarantee #1 in AI search by month two."
Nobody can guarantee this. Citation share movement takes 60–90 days for first lift and 6–14 months for category authority. Guaranteed-fast-results language is the surest sign of an inexperienced firm.
Red flag 02 · "We do AEO, GEO, AIO, AISEO, LLMSEO and LLMO."
Acronym soup is a signal of a firm rebranding for the trend rather than building one discipline well. The serious firms publish their position on the category (e.g. "AEO is the umbrella, GEO is a sub-discipline") and pick a side in writing.
Red flag 03 · "We will write fifty blog posts a month for you."
AI engines weight one original-research pillar 4–7× heavier than recycled commentary at scale. Firms selling content volume are selling old SEO under a new label. Volume is not the unit of value; cited-reference grade is.
Red flag 04 · "Our case studies are confidential."
Anonymised partner case briefings with quantified outcomes are normal and respectable. "We cannot share any work due to NDAs across the board" is usually a signal that the work to share is thin. Ask for two anonymised case briefings with named industry, named outcome and named timeline.
The firm worth hiring will be the firm that hands you a written growth-architecture recommendation before they ask for a contract. Everything else is selling. . The Cited Brand System™
Hire or build?
The honest answer for ₹50Cr–₹500Cr Indian B2B firms: hire. Building an in-house AEO function costs ₹40–80 lakh per year (senior strategist + technical SEO + content lead + designer + tools). A category-exclusive partnership costs ₹60 lakh–₹1.5Cr per year and ships a deeper, more research-anchored output because the firm runs original research across many partners.
The hire-build economics flip above ₹500Cr revenue. Firms at ₹500Cr–₹2,000Cr can afford the senior in-house function and benefit from the institutional knowledge it builds. Above ₹2,000Cr, in-house is usually the right call with a category-exclusive AEO firm running the original-research and Wikipedia-eligibility layers in parallel.
Frequently asked questions.
What is the difference between an SEO agency and an AEO agency?
SEO ranks pages in Google's blue-link results. AEO engineers whether AI engines like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude name your firm in answers. Across 247 Indian B2B firms, the correlation between SEO Domain Rating and AI citation share was r = 0.08, statistically zero. The disciplines are adjacent, not the same.
How long should an AEO engagement run before I see results?
First measurable citation lift: 60–90 days. Compounding gains: months 4–6. Category authority: 9–14 months for open Indian B2B categories, longer for crowded sub-categories. Anyone promising faster is selling pitch theatre.
How many AEO agencies should I evaluate?
Three is the right number. One reference firm to anchor what "good" looks like, one mid-tier candidate, and one preferred candidate based on category fit. Five candidates is fatigue; one is no comparison.
Should I hire a global platform (Profound, Peec) or an India-based firm?
Hybrid. The global platforms are strong on measurement and tooling but light on Indian buyer-prompt fluency, regional trade-press relationships, and multilingual entity-graph work. Most ₹50Cr+ Indian firms run a hybrid stack: India-based firm on strategy and execution, global platform on measurement layer.
What should the first conversation look like?
A 30–45 minute structured call with the firm's senior practitioner, not a sales person. You should leave with: a verbal hypothesis on your three biggest visibility gaps, a written follow-up within five business days, and a pricing range for the engagement options that fit. If those three are not there, the firm has not engaged seriously.
We will evaluate ourselves against these twelve questions.
Drop your URL and a work email. We send back a self-evaluation across the twelve questions in this article, published methodology, schema fluency, original research, pricing transparency. Five working days. Reviewed personally by Dr. Avinaash.
Apply for the free read →